Subject: [precis] 2010-12-14 Precis wg interim meeting minutes

From: Marc Blanchet <[email-masked]>
Date: Tue, 14 Dec 2010 10:16:34 -0500

Hello,
  please find the meeting minutes for the interim meeting. Thanks to all 
who participated given the early or very late time. Thanks to Peter for 
meeting notes.  Minutes are a merge of Peter's and mine. Please send 
modifications of minutes to me.

Regards, Marc, co-chair.

===========================================================
IETF Precis wg interim meeting minutes
Via Webex Teleconferencing
2010-12-14, 9h00-10h00 Eastern

Attendees:
Marc Blanchet
Peter St-Andre
Yoshiro Yoneya
Andrew Sullivan
Dave Thaler

=====================
Administrativia (chairs)

=====================
Problem statement (Sullivan)
  slides: 
http://tools.ietf.org/wg/precis/trac/attachment/wiki/InterimMeetingDec/problem-statement-slides-2010-12-14a.pdf
  Andrew suggests copying the reviews to an Appendix of the document
  Marc: put in form of a table, with some formatting/edits to make them 
consistent.
  Peter made changes to the template -- how update existing reviews?
  Marc: No need to re-open tickets, just update them via the problem 
statement
document
  Andrew: do we want to put text about unicode changes?
  Marc: yes. important input. only state the facts. do not imply the 
solution.

  next rev of problem statement draft for next interim meeting
   add text about unicode changes happened for idna2008;
   start the table with current reviews

=====================
Reviews of RFC using stringprep (all reviewers)
  Dave Thaler:
   no issue about the template;
   EAP methods are responsible for some of the stringprep processing.
   Other processing is global to all EAP methods
   review of EAP was written with the above context in mind.
  Peter St-Andre:

  Marc: proposal to wg is to complete reviews of SASL and LDAP family of 
stringprep users. Then start working on the solutions space. Then in 
parallel, complete the other reviews and work on solutions.
  Dave: agree but add RFC2282 NAI in the core set.
  Peter: NFS, iSCSI are important also.
  Marc: agree and we should get the reviews. only point is to start 
working on solutions
   even if those are not in.
  Peter: Nameprep users?;
  Marc: agree, but this is a little bit more tricky, since it is more in 
the IDNA2008 domain.
  ticket owners: chairs to ping/hassle reviewers for NAI, NFS, iSCSI
  Andrew: to my knowledge, no one has implemented IRIS.

  Agreement not to hold up start of framework efforts on getting every
review done (i.e., work on parallel)

Next steps (chairs)
   for next interim, January 18th 2011:
    - new rev of problem statement
    - reviews of at least SASL and LDAP family
    - if possible, NAI, NFS and iSCSI reviews.
    - start working on solutions space.

-- 
=========
IPv6 book: Migrating to IPv6, Wiley. http://www.ipv6book.ca
Stun/Turn server for VoIP NAT-FW traversal: http://numb.viagenie.ca
DTN Implementation: http://postellation.viagenie.ca
NAT64-DNS64 Opensource: http://ecdysis.viagenie.ca